{ "document_metadata": { "page_number": "2 of 32", "document_number": "644", "date": "03/11/22", "document_type": "Court Document", "has_handwriting": false, "has_stamps": false }, "full_text": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE Document 644 Filed 03/11/22 Page 2 of 32\n\nTable of Contents\n\nTable of Contents ............................................................................................................................... ii\nTable of Authorities ....................................................................................................................... iii\nIntroduction .................................................................................................................................... 1\nThe Facts ......................................................................................................................................... 3\nThe Law ........................................................................................................................................... 6\nI. Ms. Maxwell is entitled to a new trial....................................................................................... 6\nA. The government’s policy concerns—the abstract interest in “finality” and the so-called “disfavor” with which new trial motions are viewed—are misplaced. ............... 6\nB. Ms. Maxwell does not have to prove that Juror No. 50’s voir dire answers were deliberately false............................................................................................................................ 9\nC. Juror No. 50’s answers were deliberately false.................................................................... 14\nD. If Juror No. 50 had truthfully answered Questions 25 and 48, the correct responses would have provided a valid basis for a challenge for cause. ........................................................ 16\nE. This Court should reject the government’s attempt to manufacture a “Show Hearing”. 19\n1. The lawyers should conduct the questioning.................................................................... 19\n2. The questioning should encompass any topic on which actual bias may be based.... 21\n3. The Additional Biased Juror Should Be Questioned........................................................... 23\n4. Ms. Maxwell is entitled to Discovery................................................................................. 24\n5. Juror No. 50 is not entitled to discovery in advance of the hearing. ............................... 25\nConclusion .................................................................................................................................... 25\nCertificate of Service .................................................................................................................... 27\nii\nDOJ-OGR-00009871", "text_blocks": [ { "type": "printed", "content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE Document 644 Filed 03/11/22 Page 2 of 32", "position": "header" }, { "type": "printed", "content": "Table of Contents", "position": "top" }, { "type": "printed", "content": "Table of Contents ............................................................................................................................... ii\nTable of Authorities ....................................................................................................................... iii\nIntroduction .................................................................................................................................... 1\nThe Facts ......................................................................................................................................... 3\nThe Law ........................................................................................................................................... 6\nI. Ms. Maxwell is entitled to a new trial....................................................................................... 6\nA. The government’s policy concerns—the abstract interest in “finality” and the so-called “disfavor” with which new trial motions are viewed—are misplaced. ............... 6\nB. Ms. Maxwell does not have to prove that Juror No. 50’s voir dire answers were deliberately false............................................................................................................................ 9\nC. Juror No. 50’s answers were deliberately false.................................................................... 14\nD. If Juror No. 50 had truthfully answered Questions 25 and 48, the correct responses would Have Provided a valid basis for a challenge for cause. ........................................................ 16\nE. This Court should reject the government’s attempt to manufacture a “Show Hearing”. 19\n1. The lawyers should conduct the questioning.................................................................... 19\n2. The questioning should encompass any topic on which actual bias may be based.... 21\n3. The Additional Biased Juror Should Be Questioned........................................................... 23\n4. Ms. Maxwell is entitled to Discovery................................................................................. 24\n5. Juror No. 50 is not entitled to discovery in advance of the hearing. ............................... 25\nConclusion .................................................................................................................................... 25\nCertificate of Service .................................................................................................................... 27", "position": "middle" }, { "type": "printed", "content": "ii", "position": "footer" }, { "type": "printed", "content": "DOJ-OGR-00009871", "position": "footer" } ], "entities": { "people": [ "Ms. Maxwell", "Juror No. 50" ], "organizations": [], "locations": [], "dates": [ "03/11/22" ], "reference_numbers": [ "1:20-cr-00330-PAE", "644", "DOJ-OGR-00009871" ] }, "additional_notes": "The document appears to be a court filing related to the case of Ms. Maxwell, with a table of contents outlining various sections and subsections. The document is well-formatted and legible." }